Reclaimed Wood: Love It, But Leave These Projects Alone!
Posted by: Mark Plante Posted on: January 29, 2025

Reclaimed wood. It’s got character, it’s eco-friendly, it whispers tales of bygone eras. We adore it! But let’s be honest, sometimes that weathered charm isn’t quite right for every project. Think of it like this: you wouldn’t wear your favorite ripped jeans to a wedding, would you? (Okay, maybe some people would, but you get the point!) So, grab your safety glasses (and maybe a sense of humor), because we’re diving into the hilarious world of what not to build with reclaimed lumber.

1. Anything Food-Related (Unless You Like Splinters in Your Salad):

Okay, cutting boards and charcuterie boards can be made from reclaimed wood, but it’s crucial to be absolutely certain of the wood’s history. Did it once house toxic chemicals? Was it treated with something you definitely don’t want near your artisanal cheese? Unless you know the wood’s past better than you know your own family history, stick to new, food-safe lumber for anything that touches your culinary creations. Nobody wants a side of mystery chemicals with their dinner.

2. Anything Requiring Precise Dimensions (Unless You Enjoy Frustration):

Reclaimed wood is notorious for its inconsistencies. Warping, cupping, twisting – it’s got it all! Trying to build something with super-precise measurements, like, say, a finely tuned scientific instrument (why would you do that with reclaimed wood?!), is going to be a nightmare. You’ll spend more time wrestling with wonky wood than you will actually building. Save yourself the headache and opt for dimensioned lumber for projects where accuracy is key.

3. Anything Exposed to Extreme Moisture (Unless You’re Building a Compost Bin):

Reclaimed wood has often lived a life. It’s seen things. It’s been through things. And often, those things involve moisture. This makes it less stable than new lumber and prone to further warping, cracking, and even rot when exposed to the elements. So, unless you’re intentionally building something that’s supposed to decay (like a compost bin – perfect use for reclaimed wood!), avoid using it for outdoor projects in areas with high humidity or direct water exposure. Your beautiful reclaimed wood garden furniture might just become a fancy home for mushrooms.

4. Anything Structural (Unless You Like Living on the Edge):

While some reclaimed wood is incredibly strong, you can’t always guarantee its structural integrity. Hidden cracks, previous damage, and unknown wood species can make it risky to use for load-bearing applications. Unless you’re a structural engineer with a penchant for living dangerously, avoid using reclaimed wood for decks, roof supports, or anything that holds significant weight. Leave the structural stuff to the professionals and the properly graded lumber.

5. Anything That Needs to be Perfectly Smooth (Unless You’re a Fan of Sanding… A Lot):

Reclaimed wood is often rough and textured, which is part of its charm. But if you’re aiming for a perfectly smooth, flawless finish, you’re in for a lot of sanding. Like, a lot. Think “sanding marathon” levels of sanding. Unless you consider sanding your cardio for the day, choose new lumber for projects where smoothness is paramount.

The Bottom Line:

Reclaimed wood is fantastic! It’s sustainable, beautiful, and full of character. But like any material, it has its limitations. By understanding what not to build with it, you can save yourself time, frustration, and the occasional splinter. So, embrace the imperfections, choose your projects wisely, and happy building!